Then Raushenbush hauled out a familiar argument: “Let's just be very clear here -if you are against marriage equality you are anti-gay. The Huffington Post’s Paul Raushenbush quickly wrote up a response, saying that “The hard reality that Cardinal Dolan and all Christians need to face up to is that the Catholic Church along with every other church whether Orthodox, Protestant or Catholic has been horrifically, persistently and vehemently anti-gay for almost all of its history.” The question resurfaced last week when Cardinal Timothy Dolan, Archbishop of New York, claimed on Meet the Press that the Catholic Church is unfairly “caricatured” as anti-gay. What to make of Cardinal Timothy Dolan's claim that the Catholic Church has been unfairly caricatured as anti-gay? (Stefano Rellandini/Reuters)ĭoes being against gay marriage make someone anti-gay?